Title: The
Replacement
Author: Brenna Yovanoff
Pages: 375
Publication Date: 21st September 2010
Publisher: Simon &
Schuster
Though he lives in the small town of Gentry, Mackie comes from a world of tunnels and black, murky water, a world of living dead girls ruled by a little tattoed princess. He is a replacement - left in the crib of a human baby sixteen years ago when it was stolen away by the fey. Now, because of fatal allergies to iron, blood and consecrated ground, Mackie is slowly dying in the human world. Mackie would give anything just to be normal, to live quietly amongst humans, practice his bass guitar and spend time with his crush, Tate. But when Tate's baby sister goes missing, Mackie is drawn irrevocably into the underworld of Gentry, known as Mayhem, where he must face down the dark creatures and find his rightful place - in our world, or theirs (Goodreads)
The Replacement had a wonderfully dark, chilling tone and I
think that was reflected perfectly in the setting and its description – Brenna
Yovanoff captures Gentry perfectly. Gentry is a dreary, perennially raining and
grey town full of secrets and I had a very specific and complete image of
Gentry in my mind whilst I was reading, everything was in monotones, and I
think this enhanced my reading experience.
Also, along the lines of description, I loved how Mackie’s
allergies to thing such as blood and iron were shown and how debilitating they
would be, such as when you injure yourself or getting into a car or washing
your clothes all of which would include touching something that was harmful to
you - this highlighted how different Mackie was and made you realise how he
doesn’t fit into our world.
The protagonist, Mackie took some time to get used to, he’s
extremely detached from the world which I felt, made it hard to connect to him.
Despite this he seemed like a real guy; you know sometimes when a woman is
writing from a male perspective you can really tell and they kind of end up
like the perfect guy. Mackie? Not so much but I liked that. This realism was
reinforced with Mackie’s passion for music, my specific example was Chapter
Thirteen – ‘Applause’, in which Mackie plays the local club, Starlight, for the
first time. The gig was beautifully described, it really captured that feeling
music creates inside of you, it was pure and raw and it showed you Mackie’s
passion. That chapter was probably my favourite part of the whole book.
Another plus point was that the characters, who would swear,
did. I’m no big fan of swearing and personally don’t use swear words often but
I hate authors who skirt around the issue by not including them, especially
when a character would so obviously swear – I mean I probably would be swearing
a lot if I knew my sister had just been kidnapped and been replaced by this
weird creature.
Speaking of creatures… The darker side to Gentry, the one
full of dead girls and monsters was definitely intriguing but I feel like this
wasn’t used to its fullest potential. I don’t know why, because I’m a complete
scaredy cat, but I wanted more suspense and creepiness. I just found that that
aspect was lacking somewhat - I think
this was more to do with my heightened expectations.
However, something completely unexpected was the relationship between Mackie and his sister, Emma. It was sweet and incredibly endearing and the kind of sibling relationship that you don't see very often in YA.
Now this paragraph will be dedicated to my love of Tate
(excuse the feminist fangirling) Tate could be described as ‘Mackie’s love
interest’ and whilst that is true I think she’s so much more, not only is she
this reminding presence of what Mackie wants to be fighting for but also just a
symbol of strength. Tate was strong, independent and will definitely not suffer
fools gladly. Mackie himself says, “She knew exactly who she was,” and I think
strong female characters, who are defiant and get angry and take the bull by
the horns etc, are few and far between in YA.
However engaging I found The Replacement it wasn’t
completely engrossing, I wasn't compelled to read it in one sitting and it took
me about a week to finish. Overall it was an entertaining read, a great story
of a small town packed with secrets and mystery.